Big bad blue: A review of Noodler’s Baystate blue ink

Some things in life we rightly tend to avoid because of bad previous experiences, other though we may be wary of merely by force of reputation… The Great White shark, the Portuguese Man o’ War, the Sydney  funnel-web spider and of course Marmite to name but four. Well in the world of pen and ink there is another dark stranger in town with a whopping reputation that dissuades many from encountering it first hand, it’s the big… , the bad…, it’s Noodler’s Baystate Blue ink.

So today I thought I’d defy this particular ink’s ‘maverick’ reputation and give it a whirl and see what happens. In truth though I’ve been using it for a number of weeks having had a sample sent to me for review. Thanks again Ross. What has been the result? Read on my friend, read on…

Presentation: This ink came to me in a sample pot but if you’re new to Noodlers inks you should be aware that the packaging is never really the point, it’s the ink that counts. The standard Noodler’s 3oz (90ml) bottle is big, functional and full. Always be careful when opening a bottle of Noodlers ink, especially if it is a permanent or a ‘bullet proof’ ink, the last thing you would want is an inktastrophe. You might just live to regret it.

On Test: I’ve put this ink in a couple of my cartridge converter pens. Received wisdom told me to avoid pens with latex sacs or piston fillers that can be difficult to clean. On the whole I’ve had very little trouble with it; as long as you treat it carefully it doesn’t seem to bite.

In fact it behaves really well when treated with due respect. The blue itself  is big and bold, almost bombastic in nature (too many b’s ?). Highly saturated, it almost beats your brains in, shouting off the page for attention. As a piercing cobalt sort of blue it certainly makes an impact, it is in no way subtle. It is highly water-resistant, and exhibits no shading that I can see. It simply lays down a near permanent, solid bright blue line. I’m told that in terms of its formulation this ink is slightly basic (that’s alkaline for the uninitiated) so it needs treating with care. Noodler’s  themselves state that Baystate Blue should not be mixed with other inks except for those in the Baystate line, so you’d better listen. I’ve found too that this ink can stain, it certainly clings to the walls of the sample bottle I got it in more than any other ink I’ve seen. Get it on your hands and it’ll stay there for a while.

Summary:  Respect is the order of the day when using this ink. A friend of mine called it a ‘cruel mistress’ if not treated well and I would agree. However having said that you can’t beat it for sheer punching power. I’m buying some, respectfully of course…

Foolishly yours

© afoolwithapen and, 2016. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to afoolwithapen and with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

8 thoughts on “Big bad blue: A review of Noodler’s Baystate blue ink

  1. Love the color. It’s such a beautiful blue, in my opinion. However, I find it a bit too difficult to work with for my taste. I finally decided to stop using it, at least for now.

    1. Hi there yes the blue is extremely intense, obviously each eye is slightly different, but it’s a belter 🙂

  2. This colour is surprisingly bright enough and seems really beautiful, although it might take a bit time to dry, but overall I think it is great!

  3. I’ve been using it in the Noodler’s Charlie pen that it shipped with and it flows well and looks great but the Charlie line was too thin for me to appreciate the real Vivid nature if thecolor so I put it in a dollar pen, a med. nib with a piston filler and that maybe a b**** to clean but the line is bolder and it’s a cheap pen so it doesn’t really matter if it becomes irreparably stained.The Charlie cleaned out with bleach, no problem. Unfortunately my elderly father in law, trying to help out, knocked the bottle over so that I now have at least on the parts of my hardwood floor that were worn away with no coating almost irreparably stained. however bleach and rubbing alcohol do do wonders to clean it up on skin as well as on certain surfaces, even the wood is considerably lighter than it was where the stain is. The ink is a beauty but it does require care, and CAREFUL.

  4. My favorite blue ink by far, but nasty as a snake. It ate three of my favorite vintage pens before I realized that it was the ink and not my handling that was doing them in. Never again!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s